Tag Archives : opinion

I am about to head out to Magento Imagine to speak on queuing and scalability. So what is today’s blog post about? Dynamic typing; which has absolutely nothing to do with scalability.
Every once in a while I inject my opinions into places where they are not welcome. I have heard from people in the staticly-typed realm of how amateur dynamic typing is. Some people are interested in understanding how to use dynamic typing, others, not so much. So what I would like to do is talk about some of the arguements made against dynamic typing. Clearly PHP will be my reference point, but many of my points will be salient across many dynamically typed languages.
The biggest misconception about PHP is that it is a strictly dynamicly typed language. In other words that cannot have typed variables. Where you are using the OOP mechanisms in PHP, you have the opportunity to strictly type your variables.class Test {}
class ExecuteTest
{
public function exec(Test $test)
{
doSomethingWithTest($test);
}
}
$et = new ExecuteTest();
$et->exec(new Test());
What happens when this code gets compiled?Catchable fatal error: Argument 1 passed to ExecuteTest::exec() must be an instance of Test, instance of Test2 given, called in test.php on line 17 and defined in test.php on line 9
Fatal error. This is because the type of object passed in was incorrect. So data types do exist in PHP and many other languages. The only downside is that you need to actually run the code on your web server or in a unit test to compile it. Some would (and have argued extensively) that this is a significant drawback. There’s truth to that, but on a very limited scope. Is it a drawback? Yes. Is it signficant? Not by a long shot. Whether it’s PHP, Java, C, Perl, Ruby, VB, C#, JavaScript, etc. etc, if you deploy code that you haven’t tested then you deserve every error and every sleepless night you get. It’s called being responsible for your code. And don’t think that having your code pre-compiled is much better. I have a lot of compiled applications running on my computer. Cakewalk SONAR, Firefox, Apache, PHP (the binaries), MySQL, Tweetdeck, Java, etc., etc. And you know what? Shit still happens with compiled code! Sometimes even type-related errors! Compiling your code ahead of time as you do with C, Java, and the like does not protect you from type-based errors. Can you catch some fat-fingered errors? Sure. Are you safe? No.
For example, take this Java codeSystem.out.print(
Integer.MAX_VALUE
);
Running it provides an output of2147483647
What about this code?System.out.print(
Integer.MAX_VALUE + 1
);